🚚 FREE SHIPPING ON EVERY ORDER ⭐ THOUSANDS OF SNACKS & CANDY ⚡ FAST SHIPPING FROM NEW YORK
Snack Guides

6 Peanut Butter Fixes That Aren't a Peanut Butter Cup

Zebra bars, Mary Jane, Chick-O-Stick and three more ways to get your peanut butter fix when you are tired of the cup.

6 Peanut Butter Fixes That Aren't a Peanut Butter Cup

The peanut butter cup gets all the attention, but peanut butter has been
turning up in candy for a lot longer, in a lot more forms.

Six to try when you want something different.

1. Atkinson's Zebra bars

Crunchy peanut butter candy bars, bite-size, in a three-pound bag. They have
the flaky crunch of a peanut butter candy rather than the creaminess of a cup.

2. Mary Jane

Peanut butter and molasses taffy in the yellow wrapper, and over a century old.
This is the big individually wrapped bag, for people who are serious about it.

3. Grandma's peanut butter cookies

Big, soft peanut butter cookies, two to a pack. They are the lunchbox version
of a homemade peanut butter cookie.

4. Reese's Dipped Pretzels

Pretzels dipped in Reese's peanut butter coating. Sweet, salty and crunchy, and
much harder to stop eating than they look.

5. Reese's peanut butter sauce

A 4.5 pound bulk jar of Reese's peanut butter sauce. Over ice cream, banana slices or a warm brownie, it is the most
efficient peanut butter delivery system available.

6. Chick-O-Stick nuggets

Bite-size pieces of the crunchy peanut butter candy rolled in toasted coconut.
The nuggets are easier to share than the long bars, and easier to eat more of.

A note for parties

Peanut candy is one of the most common allergy concerns at a group event. If
you are putting any of these out, label the bowl.

SHOP THE STORY

Featured Products in This Article

Taste the snacks discussed above, shipped fast directly from our NY warehouse!

See more of our snack writing when you search Google.

Add as a preferred source on Google