Stage planks are built to be dunked. They are dense, molasses-heavy and firm
enough to survive a liquid, which is more than most cookies manage. The
question is what to dunk them into, and the answer is less obvious than it
looks.
(If you want the background — what a stage plank is and why New Orleans made
them — we covered that separately. This is purely about the dunk.)
What dunking actually does
Two things at once, and they work against each other.
Heat softens. The molasses-and-ginger crumb is firm at room temperature
and loosens quickly in a hot liquid. That is the point of dunking.
Liquid dissolves the glaze. The icing on top is the first thing to go, and
once it goes it takes the seal with it — the cookie then absorbs liquid much
faster and structural failure follows within a couple of seconds.
So the whole exercise is a race between softening and collapse, and it is
decided by about one second either way.
The two-second rule
Genuinely two seconds. Not five.
The dense crumb absorbs faster than it looks like it should, because molasses
is hygroscopic — it actively pulls moisture in. What feels like a cookie that
could take a long soak is one of the quicker failures on a tea tray.
Dunk the corner, not the flat. A corner gives you a smaller wetted area and
something dry to hold.
Coffee
The traditional answer, and the best one. Coffee's bitterness is the
correct counterweight to molasses, which is sweet in a heavy, almost savoury
way that fruit sweetness never is.
Black coffee works better than white here. Milk softens the bitterness that is
doing the work, and you end up with two sweet things.
Temperature matters more than with the others: very hot coffee accelerates the
glaze dissolving, so let it stand a minute.
Tea
Better than expected, and the most forgiving. Tea is thinner and less fatty
than milk or coffee, so it penetrates more slowly and gives you a wider margin
before collapse.
Strong black tea with the tannin still present is the version that works — it
provides the same astringent counterweight coffee does. A delicate tea gets
completely overwhelmed by the ginger and disappears.
Milk
The children's answer, and honestly the weakest for an adult. Milk adds
sweetness and fat to something already sweet and rich, so nothing cuts
through. What you get is a softer cookie and a duller flavour.
It does have one advantage: milk's fat coats the crumb slightly and slows
absorption, so milk is the most crash-resistant of the three. If you want a
long dunk rather than a good one, milk is the pick.
The ranking
If yours is too hard to dunk at all
That is a dried-out cookie rather than a bad one, and it is recoverable.
Twenty seconds beside a hot mug — not in it — softens the crumb through the
wrapper. Molasses cookies rehydrate from ambient humidity better than almost
anything else on a shelf, which is the same property that makes them so
absorbent in the first place.
Featured Products in This Article
Taste the snacks discussed above, shipped fast directly from our NY warehouse!
