Three coatings on essentially the same small cake doughnut. The base is close
to identical across the range, which makes this an unusually clean comparison —
you are ranking finishes, not products.
What the coating actually changes
Powdered is sugar dusted onto the surface. It is dry, it does not seal,
and it comes off on your fingers, the bag and whatever else is nearby. Because
it does not seal the doughnut, powdered lose moisture faster than the others.
The flavour is the least interfered-with of the three: you mostly taste the
cake. If you want to know what the base doughnut actually tastes like, this is
the one to eat.
Frosted is a set coating — a shell that hardens over the surface. It seals
the doughnut, which keeps the crumb softer for longer, and it adds a distinct
snap on the first bite that the other two do not have.
Double chocolate puts cocoa in the cake as well as the coating. Cocoa is
drying — it absorbs moisture — so this version reads denser and slightly drier
than the others even when perfectly fresh. That is the ingredient, not a
staleness problem.
The ranking, with reasons
1. Frosted. The shell does real work. It keeps the crumb moist, it adds
textural contrast, and it survives a lunchbox better than powdered. The most
complete of the three as an eating experience.
2. Powdered. The classic, and the most honest. Loses points only for
mess — which is not trivial, because a powdered doughnut eaten over a
keyboard or a car seat is a genuine event.
3. Double chocolate. Not bad, but the drying effect of cocoa in a doughnut
this small is noticeable. In a larger cake it would be balanced by more crumb;
at this size the ratio works against it.
Reasonable people rank these differently, and if you eat doughnuts for the
coating rather than the cake, double chocolate moves up.
Why they are better cold than warm
Unusual for a baked good, but true here. These are cake doughnuts with a set
or dusted finish, and warming melts the frosting into the crumb and turns the
powder to paste. Room temperature is the intended state.
The only exception is a doughnut that has gone hard, where a few seconds of
warmth helps — and even then, expect the coating to suffer.
Storing them properly
Airtight, room temperature. These stale by drying out, not by spoiling.
Do not store powdered with frosted. The powder migrates onto everything
and the frosted ones end up dusty and odd-looking.
The bag is not airtight once opened. Transfer to a container, or the
powdered ones in particular will be noticeably drier by the next day.
Freezing works and is under-used for small doughnuts. Freeze on a tray,
then bag them, and thaw at room temperature — the coating survives better
than you would expect.
A note on the variety box
If you cannot decide, the mixed box is the sensible purchase for a specific
reason: this is a range where household preferences diverge sharply, and the
powdered partisans and the frosted partisans rarely convert one another.
Featured Products in This Article
Taste the snacks discussed above, shipped fast directly from our NY warehouse!
