Carlotta's Bakery
Nostalgic Limited Batch Apple Milk Caramel Candy Squares, 1 Lb.
$19.59
🍯 Bakery & Sweet Classics • Shop by Flavor
Caramel & Toffee
59 in stock. Gourmet sea salt caramels, crunchy butter toffees, stroopwafels, and rich butterscotch.
Marzetti
Marzetti Fruit Dips & Dessert Glazes – Light Caramel, 13.5 Oz Tub
$18.54
Cracker Jack
Cracker Jacks Fun Snack Pack, 1.25 Oz, 12 Count
$19.62
Goldenberg's
Original Dark Chocolate Goldenberg's Peanut Chews, 2 Lbs
$21.76
Killer Brownie
Killer Brownie Kitchen Sink Brownie Bites, 9 oz Tray (8 Bites) - Blondie & Brownie with Caramel, Chocolate Chips, M&M’s & Sprinkles
$19.30
Killer Brownie
Killer Brownie Brookie Brownie Bites, 9 oz Tray (8 Count) – Chocolate Chip Cookie & Brownie with Caramel, Gourmet Fudgy Dessert Bars
$16.65
Tootsie Roll
Caramel Apple Sugar Babies, Candy Coated Caramels, Nostalgic, Movie Theater Box, 3 Count
$14.99
Carlotta's Bakery
Nostalgic Limited Batch Milk Caramel Candy Squares, 1 Lb.
$13.99
Long Boys
Atkinson's Coconut Long Boys Juniors Nostalgic New Orleans Chewy Candy ~ 12 Oz
$14.93
Little Debbie
Little Debbie Snack Cakes Multipack Box | Star Crunch, Cookies With Caramel and Crisp Rice
$12.99
Goldenberg's
Goldenberg's Peanut Chews Original Dark 10.5 oz. Bag
$14.99
Drake's
Drake's Devil Dogs Ultimate Variety Pack, Original, Salted Caramel, Mochaccino & Sunny Doodle, 4 Boxes, 32 Cakes
$31.52
Carlotta's Bakery
Nostalgic Limited Batch Sea Salt Milk Caramel Candy Squares, 1 Lb.
$13.99
Tootsie Roll
Tootsie Roll Limited Edition Caramel Pops, 12.46 Oz Laydown Bag
$17.99
Tribeca Curations
Black Cow Chocolate Caramel Nostalgic Bite Size Candy, 1 lb
$17.99
Drakes Wonder
Drakes Snack Cakes Multipack Box, Creme Filled Salted Caramel Devil Dogs, 8 Count Box
$13.99
Atkinson's
Atkinson's Nostalgic Vanilla Caramels, 12 oz. Bag, New Orleans Caramels
$14.99
Swedish Candy
Authentic Swedish BUBS Candy – 1 lb Tub | 4-Flavor Variety Mix: Banana Toffee, Strawberry Vanilla, Tutti Frutti & Lemon Raspberry
$21.99
Drizzilicious
Drizzilicious Mini Rice Cake Bites, Salted Caramel | 4 Bags
$27.50
Long Boys
Coconut Long Boys Juniors Nostalgic New Orleans Chewy Candy, 2 lb.
$23.93
Atkinson's
Nostalgic Candy Combo, Long Boys Juniors, Vanilla Caramels, and Black Cows, 12 oz. Each, Total 36 Oz. New Orleans Classic Caramels
$28.99
Cadbury
Cadbury Dairy Milk Fingers Variety Pack, 4 UK Imported Biscuit Boxes, Milk Chocolate, White Chocolate, Orange & Sea Salt Caramel
$27.50
Sheila G's
Brownie Brittle Salted Caramel Chocolate | 2 Full-Size Bags of Crunchy Thin Brownie Cookie Brittle
$17.99
Brownie Brittle
Sheila G's Brownie Brittle 1oz Variety - Salted Caramel / Chocolate Chip | 20 Ct
$31.00
Boyer
Boyer Candy Company Peanut Butter Cups | Gluten Free & Kosher, Smoothie Butterscotch
$13.99
Moon Pie
Moon Pie Double Decker Sandwich Cream Pies – 9 Pack | Salted Caramel
$14.99
Tribeca Curations
Marshmallow Crispy Treat Bars, Salted Caramel | 6 Pack
$22.97
Sanders
Sanders Small Batch Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels 7 Oz, 2 Packs
$24.22
Tootsie Roll
Sugar Babies Candy Coated Caramels Variety Featurig Caramel Apple, Original and Junior Caramels, Movie Theater Boxes
$14.99
Turtle Chips
Turtle Chips Korean 4-Layer Crispy Snack Chips, 2 Pack | Caramel Popcorn
$25.99
Drakes
Drake's Limited Edition Devil Dogs – 2 Boxes | Salted Caramel Chocolate Snack Cake Sandwiches
$23.76
Drakes
Drake's Devil Dogs Combo Pack – Regular & New Salted Caramel Flavor Snack Cake Cream Sandwiches | 1 Box of Each
$23.76
Sheila G's
Brownie Brittle Toffee Crunch Chocolate | 2 Full-Size Bags of Crunchy Thin Brownie Cookie Brittle
$17.99
Killer Brownie
Killer Brownie Gourmet Brownie Bites or Bars Tray | Peanut Butter Brookie Bites
$16.99
Kraft
Kraft Milk Chocolate Caramel Thins, 2 Piece Packs 12 Count Box Individually Wrapped Candy
$31.96
Nerds
NERDS Candy Corn, 8 oz Bag, 6 Dual-Flavored Fruity Combinations, Crunchy Candy Shell with Soft & Chewy Center, Halloween Candy
$14.99
Swedish Candy
Authentic Swedish Candy Bubs In a Tub 4 Flavor Variety Mix, Banana Toffee, Strawberry Vanilla, Tutti Frutti, and Lemon Raspberry, 8 Oz
$13.99
Moon Pie
Moon Pie Salted Caramel Double Decker Marshmallow Sandwich Cookies, 9 Pack
$17.29
Atkinsons
Atkinson Candy Company Nostalgic Candy Tubs – Vanilla Caramel
$13.99
Tosstie Roll
Tootsie Fall Candy Favorites | Caramel Apple Pops 1 lb Bag
$24.99
Tribeca Curations
Gourmet Small Batch Candy Corn, Caramel Apple – 1 lb.
$14.99
HBAF
HBAF Korean Imported Exotic Popcorn, 3 Pack | Caramel & Cheese
$19.99
Z!NGHA
Z!NGHA Double Herbal Inhalers | Aromatherapy Nasal Inhaler, Caffeinated Caramel Banana
$13.70
Musselman's
Musselman's Applesauce Cups | 1 Pack (4 Caramel Cups) 6 oz
$12.99
Tootsie Roll
Tootsie Fall Candy Favorites | Caramel Tootsie Pops 12.6 oz Bag
$24.99
Prairie City Bakery
Prairie City Bakery Sea Salt Caramel Ooey Gooey Butter Cake, 1 Box, 10 Cakes
$29.57
Sanders
Sanders Small Batch Mini Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels | 3.75 Oz, 4 Pack
$34.80
Sanders
Sanders Small Batch Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Caramels | 3.75 Oz, 4 Pack
$34.80
Sanders
Sanders Small Batch Mini Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels | 3.75 Oz, 4 Pack
$36.08
Little Debbie
Star Crunch Fudge Coated Cookies with Caramel & Crisp Rice Value Pack | Mega Sized 3 Oz Each || 24 Count
$34.26
Tribeca Curations
Caramel Icing Topping Packets, 1.5 oz, Great for Snack Cakes and Big Backs, 6 Packets
$12.99
Marzetti
Marzetti Fruit Dips & Dessert Glazes – Caramel, 13.5 Oz Tub
$18.54
Marzetti
Marzetti Fruit Dips & Dessert Glazes – Salted Caramel, 13.5 Oz Tub
$14.98
Tribeca Curations
Topping Packets Variety Pack: Caramel, Vanilla and Peanut Butter, Great for Big Backs Snack Cakes, 18 Packets
$19.95
Twin Bing
Twin Bing Chocolate Candy Bars – 12 Pack | Caramel
$32.00
HBAF
HBAF Korean Imported Exotic Popcorn, 3 Pack | Milk Caramel
$19.99
Kraft
Kraft Caramels Fall Candy 2 Pack | Pretzel Bark
$25.20
Kraft
Kraft Caramels Fall Candy 2 Pack | Pumpkin Spice Caramel Cups
$25.20
Kraft
Kraft Caramels Fall Candy 2 Pack Variety | Pretzel Bark Candy Corn Crunch & Pumpkin Spice Caramel Cups | 4.2 oz Bags
$25.20
Stocking your pantry, office breakroom, or snack bar? Everything ships free with no minimum, and two or more items saves 25%. All orders are packed fresh right here in our New York warehouse.