M&Ms
Candy & Cookie Peanut Butter Spread 15 oz Jar, Snickers
$23.50
🥜 Bakery & Sweet Classics • Shop by Flavor
Peanut Butter & Nut
67 in stock. Nutty peanut butter bars, crunchy nut cookies, Reese's delights, and savory-sweet nut snacks.
M&Ms
Candy & Cookie Peanut Butter Spread 15 oz Jar, Twix
$23.50
M&Ms
Candy & Cookie Peanut Butter Spread 15 oz Jar, M&Ms
$23.50
Hostess
Little Debbie Vs. Hostess 20 Snack Cake Variety Sampler Including Twinkies, Zingers, Coffee Cakes and Nutty Bar Cakes and Bars, Honeybuns, Zebra Cakes
$27.50
Carlotta's Bakery
Carlotta's Bakery Authentic New York Round Coffee Cakes (24 Oz, Cinnamon Walnut)
$25.99
Tribeca Curations
12 Pack Little Debbie Variety, Cosmic Brownie, Oatmeal Doubler Decker, Fudge Doubler Decker and Nutty Buddy, Single Serve Packs
$28.55
Chick-O-Stick
Chick O Stick Peanut Butter Coconut Candy 48 count 0.36oz Bag
$24.76
Carlotta's Bakery
Carlotta's Bakery Authentic New York Round Coffee Cakes Bundle, Apple Cinnamon, Chocolate Marble and Cinnamon Walnut
$43.99
Cracker Jack
Cracker Jacks Fun Snack Pack, 1.25 Oz, 12 Count
$19.62
Little Debbie
Little Debbie Nutty Buddy Cakes and Peanut Butter Cream Pies Combo Pack, 2 Boxes
$24.99
Goldenberg's
Original Dark Chocolate Goldenberg's Peanut Chews, 2 Lbs
$21.76
Chick-O-Stick
Chick O Stick Peanut Butter Coconut Candy 48 count 0.36oz
$24.76
Reese's
REESE'S Peanut Butter Sauce Bulk Jar, 4.5 lb
$35.78
Chick O Stick
Chick O Stick Candy Nuggets Bite Size, Peanut Butter Coconut Snack, 2 Lbs
$23.67
Drake's
Drake's Cakes Funny Bones, Chocolate and Peanut Butter Snack Cakes, 10 cakes, Pack of 2
$18.99
Mrs. Freshley's
Mrs. Freshley's Pecan Twirls Sweet Rolls | 36 Count
$28.00
Little Debbie
Little Debbie Snack Cakes Multipack Box | Nutty Buddy Bars, Chocolate Coated Peanut Butter Wafers
$12.99
Mary Jane
Fun Size Mary Jane Peanut Butter Candy 1lb. Bulk Bag
$14.99
Hostess
Little Debbie Nutty Buddy Cake vs. Drake's Funny Bones Combo Pack, Cream Filled Snack Cakes, 1 Each
$23.99
Grandma's Cookies
Grandma's Cookies 10 Pack, Peanut Butter
$21.64
Boston Baked Beans
Boston Baked Beans Classic Candy Coated Peanuts – 24 Count Mini Theater Boxes | Nostalgic Crunchy Treat
$17.99
Fieldstone Bakery
Little Debbie Nutty Buddy Bar, Large 3 oz., Individually Wrapped 2-Packs, 36 Nutty Bars
$29.42
Fieldstone Bakery
Little Debbie Large Pecan Spinwheels, Individually Wrapped, Full Box (12x 2-packs)
$23.94
Drakes Wonder
Drake's Snack Cakes Multipack Box, Funny Bones, 10 Count Box
$13.99
Goldenberg's
Goldenberg's Peanut Chews Original Dark 10.5 oz. Bag
$14.99
Carlotta's Bakery
Carlotta's Authentic Italian Rainbow Cookies | 13 Ounces
$19.99
Tribeca Curations
Little Debbie Mega Sized Cakes Combo Packs | Includes: Zebra Black & White Cakes / Cosmic Chocolate Brownies / Nutty Peanut Buddy Bars | 18 Total
$32.07
Grandma's Cookies
Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies - 33 pks - Total 66 Cookies
$34.50
Claeys
Claeys Rich & Creamy Fudge – Huge 10 oz Brick | Chocolate Walnut
$12.50
Carlotta's Bakery
Carlotta's Bakery Authentic New York Blondie With Sprinkled Walnuts Cake 18 oz, Bakery Style Coffee Cake
$19.99
Little Debbie
Little Debbie Snack Cakes Multipack Box | Pecan Spinwheels, Cinnamon Pastry Rolls
$12.99
Claeys
Claeys Rich & Creamy Fudge – Huge 10 oz Brick | Maple Walnut
$12.50
Claeys
Claeys Rich & Creamy Fudge – Huge 10 oz Brick | Peanut Butter
$12.50
Little Debbie
Little Debbie Nutty Buddy Peanut Butter Cookie Cream Pies, Family Pack
$17.99
Table Talk
Old Fashioned 4" Mini Snack Pies, 8 Pack | Pecan
$27.12
Claeys
Claeys Rich & Creamy Fudge – Huge 10 oz Brick | Vanilla Walnut
$12.50
Tribeca Curations
Little Debbie Mega Sized Cakes Variety Packs | 5 Unique Treats: Nutty Peanut Buddy Bars, Oatmeal and Fudge Double Decker Rounds, Cosmic Brownies, Zebra Cakes
$46.77
Boyer
Boyer Candy Company Peanut Butter Cups | Gluten Free & Kosher, Clark Cups
$13.99
Tribeca Curations
Little Debbie Mega Sized Cakes Combo Packs | Includes: Double Decker Fudge Rounds / Nutty Peanut Buddy Bars / Cosmic Chocolate Brownies | 18 Total
$32.87
Hershey's
Reese's Dipped Pretzels 4.25 Ounces
$12.99
Tribeca Curations
Bite Size Mary Jane Peanut Butter Candy 5 Pound Bulk Bag
$32.67
Killer Brownie
Killer Brownie Gourmet Brownie Bites Tray | Peppermint Chocolatier
$14.99
Atkinson's
Atkinson Zebra Peanut Butter Bars Sugar Free 1lb
$19.99
Mrs. Freshley's
Mrs. Freshley's Buddy Bars Peanut Butter Chocolate Wafers | 36 Total Buddy Bars
$23.15
Little Debbie
Little Debbie Nutty Buddy Peanut Butter Cakes, Family Pack
$17.99
Boyer
Boyer Candy Company Peanut Butter Cups | Gluten Free & Kosher, Smoothie Butterscotch
$13.99
Little Debbie
Little Debbie 2x Nutty Buddy Peanut Butter Cookie Cream Pies, Family Packs
$23.99
Little Debbie
Little Debbie 20 Snack Cake Variety Sampler, 10 Flavors Including Nutty Bar Cakes and Bars, Honeybuns, Zebra Cakes, Swiss Rolls
$25.76
Boyer
Boyer Candy Company Peanut Butter Cups | Gluten Free & Kosher, Peanut Butter Cup
$13.99
Tribeca Curations
Nostalgic Candy Large Movie Theater Size Boxes Variety, Boston Baked Beans, Jujyfruit, Mike & Ike, Runts, Lemonhead and Hot Tamales
$21.24
Tribeca Curations
Peanut Butter Topping Packets, .75 oz, Great for Snack Cakes and Big Backs, 6 Packets
$12.99
Tribeca Curations
Fun Size Mary Jane Peanut Butter Candy 5 Pound Bulk Bag
$32.72
Killer Brownie
Killer Brownie Gourmet Brownie Bites or Bars Tray | Peanut Butter Brookie Bites
$16.99
Tribeca Curations
Fieldstone Bakery Chocolate Covered Wafers & Peanut Butter | 24 Count Box | 2 Packs
$26.99
Little Debbie
Little Debbie 10 Snack Cake Variety Sampler, 10 Flavors Including Nutty Bar Cakes and Bars, Honeybuns, Zebra Cakes, Swiss Rolls
$23.67
Zebra Bars
Zebra Bars The Orginal Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars | Sweet & Salty Nostalgic Candy | .7 oz Bars, 24 Pack
$19.76
Zebra Bars
Zebra Bars The Orginal Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars | Sweet & Salty Nostalgic Candy | .7 oz Bars, 8 Pack
$13.92
Prairie City Bakery
Prairie City Bakery Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Ooey Gooey Butter Cakes Pack of 10
$29.57
Tribeca Curations
Mary Jane Candy | Individually Wrapped Molasses & Peanut Butter Candy | Huge 35.8 Oz (2.24 Lbs) | 130 Count Tub
$31.99
Sophie Mae
Sophie Mae Coconut Peanut Brittle Bars, 6 Count (2.25 oz Each) Made with 6 Simple Ingredients
$17.99
Zebra Bars
Zebra Bars The Orginal Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars | Sweet & Salty Nostalgic Candy | .7 oz Bars, 16 Pack
$14.84
Gurleys
Gurley's Roasted Jumbo Peanuts – 24 oz Bag | No Salt Added
$13.99
Sanders
Sanders Small Batch Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Caramels | 3.75 Oz, 4 Pack
$34.80
Wonder
Wonder Pecan Spins Cinnamon Sweet Rolls, 6 Pieces, 4 Sleeves | 24 Total
$21.99
HBAF
HBAF Korean Imported Exotic Coated Almonds, 3 Pack | Cookie & Cream
$29.20
Tribeca Curations
Topping Packets Variety Pack: Caramel, Vanilla and Peanut Butter, Great for Big Backs Snack Cakes, 18 Packets
$19.95
HBAF
HBAF Korean Imported Exotic Coated Almonds, 3 Pack | Tiramisu
$29.20
Stocking your pantry, office breakroom, or snack bar? Everything ships free with no minimum, and two or more items saves 25%. All orders are packed fresh right here in our New York warehouse.